House Speaker Paul Ryan uses charts and graphs to make his case for the GOP’s plan to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act on March 9, 2017.
J. Scott Applewhite/AP
hide caption
toggle caption
J. Scott Applewhite/AP
A new report finds that the Republican bill to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act reduce the federal deficit by $337 billion over a decade, but would also leave 24 million more Americans uninsured during that same period.
The report comes from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, and its uninsured estimates could create even greater political hurdles for the GOP bill. That legislation has already drawn opposition from major interest groups, health policy experts, and even some GOP lawmakers. The bill’s defenders in are touting the lower premiums and deficits that the CBO estimated, but they are also facing questions about what to do about tens of millions of uninsured Americans.
More uninsured, due to Medicaid and mandate repeal
Just over 28 million Americans were uninsured in the first half of 2016, according to the latest data from the Census Bureau. The CBO estimates that in 2026, that number would remain barely-changed under current law — there would likewise be 28 million uninsured Americans if the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, remained in place.
However, 52 million would be uninsured under the American Health Care Act, which is the first step in the Republican repeal-and-replace plan.
Much of the initial spike in uninsured Americans would come from repealing the individual mandate.
“Some of those people would choose not to have insurance because they chose to be covered by insurance under current law only to avoid paying the penalties, and some people would forgo insurance in response to higher premiums,” the CBO wrote.
But overall, a big chunk of that increase in the uninsured comes from Medicaid, as the Republican bill rolls back the Affordable Care Act’s Medicaid expansion. In 2026, 14 million fewer people would be enrolled in Medicaid under the GOP health care bill, accounting for half the total increase in uninsured.
In addition, CBO estimates that the Republican bill would reduce the number of employers offering health insurance, in part because it repeals the employer mandate to provide insurance. The CBO also notes that the GOP plan’s tax credits (only available to people who aren’t offered insurance at their jobs) would be available to more people than under Obamacare.
That all covers the number of people who would be insured under the legislation, but the type of people covered would also shift: namely, the people in the individual market would skew younger than they would otherwise. That’s because younger people would have comparatively more financial help, the CBO explained:
“Under the legislation, premiums for older people could be five times larger than those for younger people in many states, but the size of the tax credits for older people would only be twice the size of the credits for younger people,” they wrote.
Obamacare has had difficulties in getting enough young and healthy Americans to sign up and help bring premiums down. It appears the GOP plan would shift the balance in the individual insurance market more toward those young, healthy people. But it may not be able to do so while keeping older, less-healthy people on board as well.
If Obamacare is so great, why’d they spend tens of millions of taxpayer dollars to ‘hype’ it? BAD! #RepealAndReplacehttps://t.co/5mur5pIFQz
— President Trump (@POTUS) March 13, 2017
Premiums would rise, then fall (but not necessarily for everyone)
While the number of uninsured Americans would immediately climb, the trajectory for premiums is more complicated. In the near future, average premiums for single people buying insurance in the individual market would be up to 20 percent higher than they would be under Obamacare.
However, those premiums would eventually settle below where they would be under Obamacare. By 2026, those same premiums would be 10 percent below where they would be under the Affordable Care Act.
Importantly, that doesn’t mean that everyone’s premiums would fall. The GOP’s bill expands how much more insurers can charge older people than younger people. Under the AHCA, older Americans could be charged five times more than younger people, up from three times under current law.
That means premiums would be “substantially” smaller for younger insurance-buyers and “substantially” bigger for older Americans, the CBO wrote.
The Republicans’ new plan would reduce the deficit by just under $34 billion a year, on average, over the next 10 years. For fiscal year 2016, the total federal budget deficit was $587 billion.
The bill is just the first part of the Republicans’ plan to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act. Written as part of the budget reconciliation process, it can only make fiscal-related changes. Part 2 of the GOP’s process, as described by House Speaker Paul Ryan, will include deregulation. Part 3 will include changes to the law that could not be made in the reconciliation bill.
President Trump has not yet responded directly on Twitter to the CBO’s report. However, he did tweet shortly after the report’s release, drawing attention to a report that the Obama administration spent $77 million on promoting Obamacare in 2016.