After Medicare Drops Screening Charges, Men Head To Colonoscopy Suites

Let's do this.

Let’s do this. Frank Siteman/Age Fotostock RM/Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption Frank Siteman/Age Fotostock RM/Getty Images

More men are getting colonoscopies to screen for cancer since the Affordable Care Act reduced how much Medicare beneficiaries pay out of pocket for the preventive tests, a recent study found. The change, however, didn’t affect women’s rates.

A study, published in the December issue of Health Affairs, compared rates of screening for colorectal cancer among people age 66 to 75 before and after the health law passed in 2010. Starting in 2011, that law waived the Medicare Part B deductible (which totals $147 annually in 2015) and eliminated the requirement that beneficiaries pay 20 percent of the cost for screening colonoscopies.

The data came from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s annual Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System.

The study found that for men, colonoscopy screening rates increased from 18 percent to 22 percent following implementation of the health law. For women, the rate didn’t budge, remaining at 18 percent even after the law took effect.

The study’s finding that women didn’t respond to policy changes related to colorectal cancer screening coverage is consistent with other research, said Kandice Kapinos, the study’s co-author who is an economist at Rand, a nonprofit research and policy organization.

“Maybe they assess their risk differently because they generally have a lower incidence of colorectal cancer than men,” she said.

There is also some research that shows that women are more likely to say an endoscopic screening test such as a colonoscopy is embarrassing and to opt instead for a blood stool screening test, Kapinos said.

Under the health law, services that are recommended by the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force are covered without patients having to pay anything out of pocket. The task force recommends screening for colorectal cancer using stool testing, sigmoidoscopy or colonoscopy between age 50 and 75.

Colorectal cancer is the second-leading cause of death in cancers that affect both men and women, according to the CDC. The colonoscopy is considered highly effective as a screening tool because it can locate polyps, most of which are benign, and remove them before they have a chance to become malignant.

Screening rates are lower than they should be, however, and only 40 percent of adults are up to date, according to the study.

Under the health law, private plans can’t charge consumers a portion of the cost if, during their screening colonoscopy, a polyp is discovered and removed. That step is considered an integral part of a colonoscopy.

Under Medicare, however, beneficiaries may be charged 20 percent coinsurance in such instances. If a polyp is found, the procedure is then considered diagnostic rather than screening by Medicare. The researchers note that disparity and suggest the elimination of “the remaining difference in cost-sharing between screening and therapeutic colonoscopies could improve screening rates.”

The American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network continues to urge Congress to make the fix, says spokeswoman Alissa Crispino.

Please contact Kaiser Health News to send comments or ideas for future topics for the Insuring Your Health column. Follow Michelle Andrews on Twitter: @mandrews110.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

Foundation In Austin, Texas, Subsidizes Mental Health Care For Musicians

5:52

Download

Musicians who are dealing with mental health and substance abuse problems in Austin, Texas, can get help from an organization there that provides reduced cost care —basically whatever the musicians can afford to pay— from cooperating doctors and therapists.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

Medicaid Programs Fall Short When It Comes To Helping Smokers Quit

Bupropion, sold under the name Wellbutrin, is an antidepressant often prescribed to help a person quit smoking.

Bupropion, sold under the name Wellbutrin, is an antidepressant often prescribed to help a person quit smoking. Michelle Del Guercio/Science Source hide caption

toggle caption Michelle Del Guercio/Science Source

Smoking is the #1 cause of premature death and preventable illness in the United States. And since one-third of Medicaid participants smoke, compared to 17 percent of the general population, you’d think the states would be all about helping people in their Medicaid programs to quit.

But just 10 percent of Medicaid participants who smoke are getting medication to help them quit, according to a study published Tuesday in the journal Health Affairs. That’s 830,000 people in 2013.

Treatments include over-the-counter remedies like nicotine gum and patches, which Medicaid will pay for when a patient has a doctor’s prescription, as well as the prescription medications bupropion (Welbutrin) and varenicline (Chantix).

Some states are doing a lot better than others at helping people quit. Massachusetts and Minnesota, which have gone out of their way to promote smoking cessation to Medicaid enrollees, have among the highest treatment rates among Medicaid participants, with more than 20 percent of smokers getting at least one prescription in 2013, the study found.

But Alabama, Arkansas, Kansas, Mississippi, Rhode Island and Texas had rates below 7 percent. “The states that are doing less are also the states that have higher rates of smoking,” says Leighton Ku, lead author of the study and director of the Center for Health Policy Research at George Washington University.

And that’s costing a lot.

State and federal governments shell out about $70 billion a year to pay for smoking-related health costs through Medicaid, which insures people with low-incomes. But the program spent just $103 million on tobacco cessation medications in 2013, the study authors estimate.

States that didn’t expand their Medicaid coverage under the Affordable Care Act tend to have lower rates of medication use. And some states charge Medicaid participants copays for medication, which can discourage use. That’s not the case for people with private insurance or Medicare, which are required by the Affordable Care Act to cover prescription cessation meds without a copay.

“And finally, there have not been the kind of education programs saying, gee, this is something we can actually do something about,” Ku says.

“Everyone knows it’s hard to stop smoking,” Ku adds. “I think that makes people reticent, knowing how hard it is.” But that doesn’t mean it isn’t worth a try. “Even if you relapse, you’ve helped your health. You’ve helped your health because you’ve stopped for a while.”

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

Paramedic Shares His Wild Ride Treating 'A Thousand Naked Strangers'

Former paramedic Kevin Hazzard says he received "zero training" before driving an ambulance for the first time.
34:02

Download

Former paramedic Kevin Hazzard says he received “zero training” before driving an ambulance for the first time. iStockphoto hide caption

toggle caption iStockphoto

In the 10 years he spent driving an ambulance in Atlanta, former paramedic Kevin Hazzard rescued people from choking, overdoses, cardiac arrest, gunshot wounds and a host of other medical emergencies.

He frequently found himself practicing medicine in unsafe settings, either along the side of a highway as cars whipped past, or at the scene of an assault, where either the patient or the spectators might have weapons. “There are a lot of situations like that where it’s just not practical to wait for it to be completely safe and you gotta just try to weigh the odds,” Hazzard tells Fresh Air’s Terry Gross.

In his new book, A Thousand Naked Strangers, Hazzard chronicles his experiences as a paramedic — and explains how it is that so many of his patients came to him partially clothed.

Kevin Hazzard worked as a paramedic for 10 years in Atlanta.

Kevin Hazzard worked as a paramedic for 10 years in Atlanta. Lauren Pressey/Simon & Schuster hide caption

toggle caption Lauren Pressey/Simon & Schuster

“There’s just the huge range of people for whatever reason — whether it’s mental illness or just had way too much fun last night — find themselves out in the street partially or completely naked and need to be dealt with in one way or another,” Hazzard says.

But Hazzard says that even when he saved a life, his patients weren’t always grateful. “Just as you’re expecting a thank-you, someone says, ‘Hey, when you pulled me off that balcony that I was dangling from, you ripped my shirt!’ “


Interview Highlights

On why he always moves out of the way of ambulances

There’s a presumption that when you see an ambulance or a firetruck or a cop car that the person behind [the wheel] is a professional — they’ve been trained and they know. I received zero training. My first job was with a private ambulance service … taking people to and from appointments. There was no training program. There was really no hiring process. They never verified they actually had my EMT numbers. They asked. I said, “Yes.” They believed me; they gave me a job. …

So I showed up that first morning, and my partner handed me the keys. I just assumed he was going to be driving. So we go to breakfast and within a few minutes we get a call, and the next thing I know I’m racing down the street and he’s like, “Turn your lights on! Flip over! Cross the double yellow line! Switch back! Blow your horn!” My friends will tell you, I’m a horrible driver, so me behind this 15,000-pound ambulance screaming down the street, cars peeling out of the way, immediately removed all [my] confidence in people coming at me with sirens. I move now, really fast.

On why respiratory calls can be the most rewarding

Respiratory calls are really, really common — which was great because there are few things that you can do outside of the hospital that take someone from near death to looking at you and saying, “Do I still need to go?” And respiratory is one of those calls. We ran so many of them on everything from infants to the elderly, it was great. Everybody thinks shooting is exciting, “Oh, man, I’m going to run to this shooting, and I’m on my way!” And it’s crazy. There are cops there and police helicopters and it’s madness, but there’s really nothing for you to do. That’s really a job for the surgeons. Whereas a respiratory call, that person is in acute distress and they are going to die, you can see it in their face, and they know it and you know it. And you just happen to have this bag full of tricks that you get to kneel on their floor and talk to them and calm them down and slowly begin to give them one medication after another. Sometimes it doesn’t work, sometimes you throw the book at them and they’re still just about as dead as when you found them, but oftentimes you can make a huge difference in that person’s life, and it’s both rewarding and exciting because you wouldn’t be there if you didn’t want to open your bag and start throwing medicine at people.

On treating “speedball” overdoses, in which the patient has mixed heroin and cocaine

The one that can be the trickiest is the person who has overdosed. So you arrive, and they have all the signs of a heroin overdose, and so you have Narcan, which immediately reverses some of the effects, basically the central nervous system effects of the heroin. So, the heroin, when there’s too much of it, it essentially tells your brain, “Hey, there’s no reason to breathe, just relax, you’re good.” And that’s how people die. So you show up, there’s a guy with needles, brown powdery substance, he’s blue, and you think, “Oh, heroin overdose, this is no big deal, I’ve done this 10,000 times.” And you give him some Narcan thinking, “Hey, I’m just going to make him breathe.” Now the heroin’s gone and all that cocaine is still there, and he pops up and he’s like, “Hey! What did you do to my heroin?” And now you’ve got this very large, very angry, very confused person running around with a head full of coke, and you’re usually in the backseat of a car or crammed into a tiny little bathroom, or a bathroom stall in a restaurant, and all of a sudden this person pops up, and invariably they’re bigger than you and stronger than you and they’re half-naked and sweaty, so you can’t get a grip anyway. Those get ugly in a hurry.

On Do-Not-Resuscitate orders

If you think about it, [at] Thanksgiving you can’t even get all your family members to agree on whether they want fresh or canned cranberry sauce, right? I mean, the simplest decision in the world, and you will get four brothers who will fight to the death because they all have a different opinion, and then add to that, now, that decision is what to do if mom drops on the floor. A lot of times, it kind of depends on who the first person is to arrive. Does she live with one of the sons who wants her to be revived? Does she live with one of the children who doesn’t? Even if there’s a DNR that has been signed, oftentimes people can’t find it. So then you have to say, “OK, we don’t have, technically speaking, a valid DNR, so we have no choice but to work,” and the family will get angry with you and say, “No, no, no, that’s not what she wanted!” But you can’t prove to me that’s not what she wanted, and how do I know that you don’t have a sister who is on her way right now who knows that there’s no DNR and who is gonna come flying through that door and wonder why we’re not doing anything?

On delivering babies

Delivering babies is a huge mess in an ambulance. Hospitals are really well-suited for it. So it was such a tricky thing, because when you got one of those calls, your first reaction would sort of be dread: “Oh, no, there’s so much I’m going to have to do here, this is such a circus.” Hopefully they were at least in an accessible place, not in a car on the highway, which just really complicates everything. It’s one of those things that it’s not good until it’s all over with. Don’t forget, these are people who are enduring a natural childbirth, so they aren’t happy to see us. There’s no joking with a woman who is way deep into a natural childbirth and is going to do it on the living room rug. She’s not in the mood to smile or necessarily even be cooperative. … All of a sudden there’s this child and everybody is smiling. … It wasn’t one you always looked forward to, but it was one in the end that everybody always seemed to enjoy.

On how he knew it was time to retire from being a paramedic

There were a couple little hints and warning signs. I ran a shooting one day, and I got too close to the person and stepped on a piece of their skull. And I didn’t realize it until I got home the next morning, and it was stuck in the tread of my boot, and I thought it was a stone. And I pulled it out and it was skull fragment. I sort of laughed. My wife was horrified, and the look on her face let me know that, oh, wow, my outlook has swung in a weird direction and that’s troubling.

Those things happen little by little over time, and I guess there are hints and warnings that, hey, you’re being a little too cavalier about what you’re doing. But the moment that it hit me … it was a woman who she was caught in bed with her son-in-law by her daughter, and the son-in-law jumped out, and the daughter beat the mother with a bat. And we got there and she was really badly injured, and she was on the floor at our feet, and this crazy scene is happening all around us — helicopters and cops and this patient who desperately needed our help — and I remember yawning, and it was probably 2 in the morning and I yawned. It wasn’t like I didn’t care whether or not good things happened to this woman. I had done it so many times that there was a certain ho-hum nature about it, and there can be nothing ho-hum about trying to save someone’s life. And when you begin to think, “Well, I’ve done this before and I’ll just do it again and I’m just doing a job,” that’s when you make mistakes. And that was the first real indication to me that, man, I’ve been at this too long and I need to go ahead and get out.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

A Palliative Care Doctor Weighs California's New Aid-In-Dying Law

Van Zyl and Garcia Flores hold hands as van Zyl promises to do everything she can to ease his pain and control symptoms.
4:29

Download

Van Zyl and Garcia Flores hold hands as van Zyl promises to do everything she can to ease his pain and control symptoms. Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health New/Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health News hide caption

toggle caption Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health New/Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health News

When she first heard that California’s new aid in-dying law was signed, Dr. Carin van Zyl was relieved to hear that assisted death would be an option for her if she ever needed it herself. But as a palliative care doctor at the University Of Southern California Keck School Of Medicine, she’s worried the law might lead people to consider lethal medications over other options that may better accommodate their wishes.

“Patients feel as though their choices are between untreated suffering or physician-assisted suicide,” she told NPR’s Renee Montagne. “Palliative medicine, when it’s applied skillfully and at the right time, often relieves most of the suffering that prompts people to ask for [death] in the first place,” she says.

Van Zyl is head of palliative care medicine at Los Angeles County-USC Medical Center.

Van Zyl is head of palliative care medicine at Los Angeles County-USC Medical Center. Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health New/Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health News hide caption

toggle caption Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health New/Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health News

But palliative care, which is focused on managing symptoms and relieving pain, isn’t available to everyone, van Zyl says. There are smaller hospitals that don’t have palliative medicine teams, and it may be hard to get treatment even in urban areas. Van Zyl thinks more work should be done to make palliative medicine more accessible. “I worry that we make [lethal medication] available before we put the necessary effort forward,” she says.

Not everyone can be helped with palliative care, van Zyl says, and some people truly would have benefited from the aid-in-dying law had it been passed earlier. “I think about those patients all the time. I do recall a patient who understood that his death would be sudden and unpredictable and likely quite painful.”

He had a cancer that had spread and become intractable. A tumor developed in his neck that was swelling into both an artery and his windpipe; eventually it would connect the two. “This gentleman with very little warning might have his airways flooded with blood, and he would drown,” van Zyl says. “He asked if it would be possible to shorten his life before that.”

The care team was able to administer pain medication that would ease his death when it happened, which worked, van Zyl says, but he wasn’t able to die in the way he wanted — at home, surrounded by his family. Aid in dying would have offered more control over his situation, van Zyl says.

Still, the reasons why people choose aid in dying can be complicated. “You’ll notice in the Oregon data, many people chose this option not because of physical suffering. It was the loss of dignity, control and independence,” she says. “I would imagine writing a prescription for somebody for whom palliative sedation is not an option or would not relieve intolerable physical distress. I struggle with emotional and existential requests.” Times like that, van Zyl says she would rather administer palliative care.

Dr. Carin van Zyl talks to patient Jose Garcia Flores about his treatment options for his advanced stage colon cancer in October.

Dr. Carin van Zyl talks to patient Jose Garcia Flores about his treatment options for his advanced stage colon cancer in October. Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health New/Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health News hide caption

toggle caption Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health New/Heidi de Marco/Kaiser Health News

Choosing the best course of action is a conversation that van Zyl says she’ll continue to have with her patients. “Palliative medicine discussions are about learning the story of the person, helping this patient navigate choices. If [death] is an option that gets them closest to the things they hold dearest, then we will explore those things honestly.”

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

Forgot Something Again? It's Probably Just Normal Aging

Todd Davidson/Getty Images/Illustration Works

Todd Davidson/Getty Images/Illustration Works

Losing your ability to think and remember is pretty scary. We know the risk of dementia increases with age. But if you have memory lapses, you probably needn’t worry. There are pretty clear differences between signs of dementia and age-related memory loss.

After age 50, it’s quite common to have trouble remembering the names of people, places and things quickly, says Dr. Kirk Daffner, chief of the division of cognitive and behavioral neurology at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston.

The brain ages just like the rest of the body. Certain parts shrink, especially areas in the brain that are important to learning, memory and planning. Changes in brain cells can affect communication between different regions of the brain. And blood flow can be reduced as arteries narrow. Simply put, this exquisitely complex organ just isn’t functioning like it used to.

Forgetting the name of an actor in a favorite movie, for example, is nothing to worry about. But if you forget the plot of the movie or don’t remember even seeing it, that’s far more concerning, Daffner says.

When you forget entire experiences, he says, that’s “a red flag that something more serious may be involved.” Forgetting how to operate a familiar object like a microwave oven or forgetting how to drive to the house of a friend you’ve visited many times before can also be signs something is wrong.

But even then, Daffner says, people shouldn’t panic. There are many things that can cause confusion and memory loss, including health problems like sleep apnea, high blood pressure, or depression, as well as medications like antidepressants. Even over-the-counter remedies like antihistamines can contribute to memory loss.

You don’t have to figure this out on your own. Daffner suggests going to your doctor to check on medications, health problems and other issues that could be affecting memory.

And the best defense against memory loss is to try to prevent it by building up your brain’s cognitive reserve, Daffner says.

“Read books, go to movies that challenge, take on new hobbies or activities that force one to think in novel ways,” he says. In other words, keep your brain busy and working. And get physically active, Daffner says, because exercise is a known brain booster.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

How Uganda Came To Earn High Marks For Quality Of Death

A elderly patient with chronic debilitating back pain receives a bottle of liquid morphine during a home visit from a representative of Hospice Africa Uganda.

A elderly patient with chronic debilitating back pain receives a bottle of liquid morphine during a home visit from a representative of Hospice Africa Uganda. Morgana Wingard/African Palliative Care Association hide caption

toggle caption Morgana Wingard/African Palliative Care Association

Dr. Anne Merriman is determined to give the dying relief from pain in their last days.

Dr. Anne Merriman is determined to give the dying relief from pain in their last days. Courtesy Hospice Africa Uganda hide caption

toggle caption Courtesy Hospice Africa Uganda

Food coloring, water, a preservative and a pound of morphine powder. These are the ingredients in Dr. Anne Merriman’s recipe for liquid morphine.

“It’s easier than making a cake,” says Merriman, a British palliative care specialist who founded Hospice Africa in Uganda in 1993 and helped design the formula that hospice workers in Uganda have used for 22 years to craft liquid morphine. The lightest dose, dyed green to indicate the strength and to make sure people don’t confuse it with water, costs about $2 per bottle to make. Stronger doses are dyed pink and blue. A 16-ounce bottle is about a week’s supply for most patients.

Those cheap bottles of green, pink and blue liquid morphine have changed the way people die in Uganda — and are a key reason why Uganda has the best quality of death among low-income countries, according to global Quality of Death Index published by the Economist Intelligence Unit.

Back in the 1990s, two of the biggest barriers to good death in Uganda were simple: not enough doctors and not enough morphine. Largely through Merriman’s drive, Hospice Africa Uganda developed professional education in palliative care that would spread the responsibility to nurses, rather than relying on doctors. They helped make it mandatory for medical students in Uganda to study pain management -– before Germany did. And Hospice Africa Uganda made liquid morphine.

“I had been one of the doctors who had said to people, ‘Sorry, there is no more we can do. You have to go home,'” says Merriman, of the time she spent working with cancer patients in Singapore starting in the 1960s. There, she says, “I found that patients with cancer were getting every treatment possible with chemotherapy, and then when it didn’t work they were sent home and they were dying in agony.”

So she sat down with a couple pharmacists from the National University Hospital and came up with a formula to make a liquid from pure morphine powder.

An HIV-positive woman, living alone in a one-room house, speaks with a visiting doctor.

An HIV-positive woman, living alone in a one-room house, speaks with a visiting doctor. Morgana Wingard/African Palliative Care Association hide caption

toggle caption Morgana Wingard/African Palliative Care Association

Merriman would eventually be invited to Kenya to set up a hospice care program in Nairobi before founding her own organization in 1993, based in Uganda. At that time, palliative care in Africa only existed in Zimbabwe and South Africa, and the services, she says, were “started out by whites for whites.” Medication was prohibitively expensive for most patients. “The strongest they had there was codeine — if you had money. But if you didn’t have money, you only had aspirin and sometimes nothing at all,” says Merriman.

Today, the organization’s three hospice centers serve some 2,100 outpatients. “It’s not always the pain that’s their greatest worry,” she says. “It’s often ‘What’s going to happen to my children when I die?’ It may be spiritual problems, it may be cultural — things they have to carry out before they die. We try to help with all those kinds of things.”

Relieving pain is step one — and it has many benefits. Patients eat better, sleep better and live higher quality lives, even in their last days, says Merriman.

Cost was one obstacle to pain management that Merriman had to address. Another, which persists in many countries, was a deep-rooted fear of opioid painkillers.

Though morphine is considered the gold standard in palliative care for pain management, in many parts of the world fear of opioid addiction and misuse is so rampant it has a name: opiophobia.

Merriman ran up against opiophobia in Singapore and Uganda, where she says, people thought she was providing morphine so that patients could kill themselves. “And morphine can kill,” she says. But with the right regulations in place, and the right explanation to the patient and their relatives, she says, “it’s very safe.”

For over a decade, the Ugandan government has provided morphine free to the patients of prescribers who are members of a special registry, all trained through Hospice Africa Uganda.

“You’ve got to be careful, everything has to be signed for and we have to follow the regulations,” she says. “But for the last three years, we’ve been making morphine for the whole country.”

Merriman says of the 24,000 patients in total that they have prescribed oral morphine to, “we’ve had no addiction, no diversions. And the patients keep the bottle at home.”

In Uganda, she had to work hard to surmount the fear of opioids. For example, Hospice Africa Uganda worked with narcotics police, teaching them what morphine is and that it’s a legal medication.

“They need to understand that patients can take morphine and that they are not addicted, that it is handed to patients after careful assessment, and that it is a safe medication,” says Dr. Eddie Mwebesa, clinical director at Hospice Africa Uganda. Without police cooperation, he says, “there will be a lot of trouble with patients having their morphine in the home” and in transporting the drug between hospices or patient homes.

Clinicians prescribe the morphine and instruct patients to sip a dose from a marked cup. For adults, it’s usually about a teaspoon every 4 hours. Merriman says hospice workers frequently have to warn people about morphine — not because of the risk of addiction but to explain that it will not wipe out their illness. She says they feel so good after it, they often feel normal again. “They think we’ve cured them,” she says.

Even with the innovations in Uganda, there are still challenges. The organization estimates that only 10 percent of Ugandan patients in need of palliative care can access it.

“The biggest challenge we have right now is the sheer number of patients who need palliative care,” says Mwebesa — he puts the number at 250,000 to 300,000. But there is about one doctor for every 20,000 Ugandans, he says.

Mwebesa says palliative care can cost about $25 each week for one patient. “It doesn’t sound like a lot,” he says, “But actually most people can’t afford it.” Only 2 percent of Ugandans have health insurance, so many families have to pay out-of-pocket to care for sick relatives.

A palliative care physician visits an HIV-positive patient who lost her family to the AIDS epidemic. She's resting on a mat outside her home.

A palliative care physician visits an HIV-positive patient who lost her family to the AIDS epidemic. She’s resting on a mat outside her home. Morgana Wingard/African Palliative Care Association hide caption

toggle caption Morgana Wingard/African Palliative Care Association

Even though Uganda is far from perfect, it remains in many respects a model country for its neighbors. “We had the minister of Swaziland visit Uganda to see how Uganda reconstitutes oral morphine and then when we went back, they started doing the same,” says Dr. Emmanuel Luyirika, executive director of the African Palliative Care Association. He says the same happened with Rwanda and Malawi.

Merriman is now turning her attention to French-speaking countries in Africa. She says some countries in the region remind her a lot of Uganda back in the ’90s. “They’ve got a fear of morphine. Doctors don’t want to prescribe it because they think if they prescribe it, they’ll be accused of being addicts themselves,” she says. World Bank data shows the region has the world’s highest maternal mortality and lowest national health budgets. And people there largely pay for health care out-of-pocket.

“If you haven’t got money,” says Merriman, “you can’t even get an aspirin.” At age 80, she’s still determined to see that the dying don’t have to face such dilemmas when they seek relief from pain.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

Cleveland Pressures Hospitals To Keep ERs Open To All Ambulances

East Cleveland medic Anthony Savoy says his city's ambulances are diverted frequently to a hospital further away, and that can add one or two minutes to response times.
3:44

Download

East Cleveland medic Anthony Savoy says his city’s ambulances are diverted frequently to a hospital further away, and that can add one or two minutes to response times. Sarah Jane Tribble/WCPN hide caption

toggle caption Sarah Jane Tribble/WCPN

When East Cleveland’s emergency medical squad gets called to treat a man with a severe nosebleed, it’s a pretty run-of-the-mill case.

The patient walks woozily out to the ambulance from a tan house on a tree-lined street. Anthony Savoy, the head medic, calls ahead to University Hospitals, which has the closest emergency room. Savoy wants to make sure the ER has space for the patient.

The man gets in that day, but it was by no means guaranteed. For years, it’s been common practice for University Hospitals to switch its status to diversion.

That means when Savoy would call the hospital, people in the emergency department would say they didn’t have the room or the staff to handle the patient. The EMS team then would have to drive to another hospital — often the Cleveland Clinic — about a mile away.

“If we get diverted and then we get a call while we’re at the hospital, our response time will be lengthened by maybe a minute, maybe two minutes,” Savoy says.

A minute or two delay may not seem like much, but it can be crucial for some patients, says Dr. James Feldman, an emergency medicine doctor in Boston. “We have strong evidence that people who have critical illness or injury who have a delayed time to treatment do worse,” he says. Patients who have had a stroke or a heart attack are prime examples.

A study released earlier this year found that heart attack patients whose ambulances were diverted from crowded emergency rooms to hospitals farther away were more likely to be dead a year later. And before that study came out, the Institute of Medicine had taken a look at the increasing use of diversions by hospitals nationwide, and recommended against that sort of rerouting.

Yet, emergency departments across the country, including those in Cleveland, continued to divert patients — often stepping up the frequency. Boston’s Feldman says hospitals across the country routinely operate with thin staffing and find themselves coping with too many patients.

In Cleveland this year, University Hospitals temporarily closed its main campus emergency room to certain patients for more than 550 hours. Another large health system, MetroHealth, clocked more than 400 diversion hours.

Jane Dus, chief nursing officer at University Hospitals, says an aging population and hospital closures have increased the demand on emergency departments. “We’ve seen a 56 percent increase in our squad volume over five years,” she says. “So we’re getting many more squads coming to us.”

Dus recently joined Cleveland-area hospital leaders in negotiating an agreement to stop ER diversion. Indeed, all four major health systems in Cleveland say they will accept all ambulances starting Feb. 15.

If the hospitals are successful, the region will join a select few that have tackled the issue. After years of trying, the Seattle area has stopped nearly all diversions.

Under federal law, every hospital is required to evaluate patients who arrive in the ER, and stabilize them before transferring them elsewhere. But the law doesn’t cover patients in ambulances that are diverted before patients are ever seen.

Massachusetts passed regulations in 2009 to ban ambulance diversions after voluntary attempts failed. Feldman says hospitals there had to reevaluate operations, in some cases urging doctors and patients to schedule elective surgeries closer to the weekends to free more hospital beds throughout the week.

But changing the way an ER responds is complicated because emergency departments routinely operate with minimum staffing and beds, Feldman says. “The staff are reasonably fearful that the next critical patient is going to push them over the brink of patient safety,” he says. “They really can’t handle another patient.”

Dr. Alfred Connors, MetroHealth’s chief clinical officer, says there are things the hospital can do to be better prepared. “This does obligate us to take steps to correct problems that are correctable that will allow us not to go on diversion,” Connors says. “It’s not just simply, ‘We’re not going to go on diversion,’ and everybody just sits and hopes that everything will be better.”

Adding bed capacity and refocusing on staff are part of the fix, he says. “It’s an issue of, do we have enough beds open, do we have the proper staffing, do we have the capacity in the emergency room.”

MetroHealth is frequently the busiest emergency department in the city, and the hospital has struggled with diversions before, logging nearly 1,000 hours of diversion in 2013. Connors says the hospital worked to reduce that number, getting down to less than 150 hours of diversion status in 2014. But in 2015, diversions rose again.

There are two hospitals in Cleveland that rarely if ever go on diversion: the Cleveland Clinic’s main campus and St. Vincent Charity Medical Center.

The Cleveland Clinic’s main campus logged more than 500 hours of ambulance diversions in 2013, but reduced its diversions to two episodes lasting a total of about 10 hours in 2015.

Dr. Stephen Meldon, a leader in the emergency department at the Cleveland Clinic, says change has to happen beyond the emergency department. The clinic has diversions at other regional hospitals in its system and will have to stop those as well, if it’s to meet the demands of the new ban.

The ban will “drive people to actually address efficiencies throughout the day,” Meldon says, “and not use diversion as a crutch, to not be doing the work they should be doing.”

The small St. Vincent Charity Medical Center in downtown Cleveland hasn’t gone on diversion since 2012. “It’s a matter of working together as a team,” says Beverly Lozar, the hospital’s chief nursing executive. “It starts every morning at 8:30. We have a huddle of all the nursing directors and all of the other clinical and support directors just to kind of review the day.”

Still, Savoy is skeptical that University Hospitals and MetroHealth can end diversions. Just hours after Savoy dropped off his nosebleed patient, University Hospitals stopped taking all but the most critical injuries for nearly four hours.

“My concern is, all of a sudden you guys are willing to put this on paper and say that you’re going to do this,” he says. “What was stopping you guys before? You know, why now?”

Savoy and others on the squad are worried that the emergency departments will stay crowded. It’s something local leaders say they’ll work to avoid.

This story is part of NPR’s reporting partnership with WCPN and Kaiser Health News.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

N.J. Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure Lowest-Paid Employees

Duke Gillingham, president of Oasis Foods, in Hillside, N.J., says about two-thirds of his roughly 180 employees declined to enroll in the company health plan for 2015. Many make less than $15 an hour, and found the company plan too expensive.
4:41

Download

Duke Gillingham, president of Oasis Foods, in Hillside, N.J., says about two-thirds of his roughly 180 employees declined to enroll in the company health plan for 2015. Many make less than $15 an hour, and found the company plan too expensive. Fred Mogul/WNYC hide caption

toggle caption Fred Mogul/WNYC

Butter-flavored popcorn oil is in high demand at Oasis Foods, a manufacturer of cooking oils, mayonnaise and other products that restaurants and distributors often purchase by the ton.

“We get a rush this time of year with all the movie-going at the holidays,” says Duke Gillingham, president of Oasis, at his factory in Hillside, N.J., just west of Newark Liberty Airport.

The company’s health insurance coverage is not as popular as its popcorn oil. Oasis offered health insurance to all employees for 2015, to comply with a new Affordable Care Act mandate. And while some employees did sign up for the insurance — the company doubled the number of people on its health plan over previous years — about two-thirds of the employees declined the coverage. With monthly premiums of roughly $350 for a family of four, and with a $2,500 annual deductible, it was too expensive for factory workers, many of whom earn between $10 and $15 an hour.

Gillingham says he hasn’t been able to find decent insurance much cheaper than that, and he cannot afford to significantly raise his employees’ wages.

“The sad fact is we’re in a very competitive business,” he says. “We wish we could make [insurance] more affordable, but it’s essentially what the business can bear. If we don’t watch what we’re doing, we can be high-cost, and that doesn’t serve any of the employees well.”

Companies Look To Avoid Penalties

Oasis Foods, a subsidiary of a Swedish food manufacturer, has about 180 workers. As of Jan.1, smaller firms — those that employ between 51 and 100 workers — are being phased into the same mandate that Oasis faced in 2015. Companies must offer affordable coverage to all employees, and will be subject to a penalty if their workers instead turn to the health exchange to buy subsidized coverage.

There’s no penalty for companies, it turns out, if workers qualify for Medicaid — though there could be controversy.

At firms like Oasis, low-wage workers are candidates more often for Medicaid than for the state or federal insurance exchange.

To qualify for Medicaid, applicants may earn no more than 138 percent of the federal poverty level — or roughly $16,000 for a single person and around $33,000 for a household of four.

Employers have not historically played a significant role in helping workers enroll in Medicaid. But Gillingham’s insurance broker told him about a startup called BeneStream, which is based in New York City and facilitates enrollment in the government program.

Company Shifts Insurance Costs To The Government

Founded two years ago with seed money from the Ford Foundation, BeneStream now helps more than 6,500 workers at 125 companies across the country get Medicaid. CEO Benjamin Geyerhahn says moving workers from private insurance to Medicaid helps firms shift their costs to the government.

“The savings is quite significant,” he says. “Our average is about 250 percent — so about two-and-a-half times the money you spend on us comes back to you in the form of saved premium.”

Geyerhahn says going onto Medicaid, which is nearly free for employees, is a good deal, though it lacks the generous benefits of more expensive plans. If employees make so little that they’re eligible for Medicaid, he says, they probably can’t afford regular insurance premiums, especially when combined with the high deductibles that undermine much of the benefit of insurance.

“Yes, this [level of coverage] is something that will help them if they get in a car accident or have a heart attack,” he says, “but this isn’t something that’s going to help them manage their health over the course of the year.”

Wal-Mart, McDonald’s and some large companies have drawn fire for not providing employees with health insurance, but instead relying on taxpayers to fund workers’ health needs via Medicaid.

Ken Jacobs, chair of the University of California, Berkeley’s Labor Center, says companies whose workers get Medicaid should bear some of the burden of the cost to taxpayers.

Critics Think Employers Should Pay Bigger Share

“Those employers should be paying more into the general pot that pays for health care, rather than putting those costs onto everyone else,” he says.

California legislators considered imposing a state tax penalty for companies whose workers get Medicaid, but lawmakers ultimately rejected the proposal.

Linda Blumberg, an economist at the Urban Institute, says that whether you are looking at a vast company like Wal-Mart or a modest-sized one like Oasis Foods, compensation is about trade-offs. The more you pay for people’s insurance, the less you have to put in their paychecks.

“When workers are low-income,” Blumberg says, “I would rather that we publicly finance their medical care, make it very accessible to them, have low cost-sharing so that’s not a barrier to them getting necessary care, and let them have a little bit higher wages in order to compensate.”

And even the large increases in the minimum wage currently being contemplated or phased in by several states and cities might still not be enough for those workers to afford most employer-sponsored insurance, given the high premiums and deductibles of such plans.

At Oasis, Gillingham says his company pays a lot in taxes, so getting almost-free health care for some workers amounts to a “fair deal.”

He contrasts this system to one he and his family of six experienced in England.

“My kids didn’t suffer from having a five- or six-minute checkup,” he says, compared with doctor visits in the United States — that may have been twice as long, and at much higher expense, but without any noticeable difference in results.

“We didn’t see any of the demons that people speak of when they talk about socialized medicine,” Gillingham says. “There were no lines, no poor standard-of-care.”

But despite being relatively upbeat about government healthcare, he concedes that Oasis workers so far have given Medicaid mixed reviews. Some doctors and hospitals take the insurance, but many don’t.

Still, that’s true of most health insurance, Gillingham says.

A Gallup poll last month found that 67 percent of Americans, in general, are satisfied with the country’s health care system, compared with 75 percent of people who are on Medicaid.

“I think the system is evolving,” Gillingham says. “I don’t know where it’s going to go, but I know it’s going to change, and we need to adapt and make use of the system in the best way possible.”

This story was produced as part of NPR’s partnership with WNYC and Kaiser Health News.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.

Obamacare Insurers Sweeten Plans With Free Doctor Visits

If your insurer waived the fee to see your primary care doctor, would you go more often?

If your insurer waived the fee to see your primary care doctor, would you go more often? Getty Images/Hero Images hide caption

toggle caption Getty Images/Hero Images

Health insurers in several big cities will take some pain out of doctor visits in 2016. The plans will offer free visits to primary care doctors in their networks.

You read that right. Doctor visits without copays. Or coinsurance. And no expensive deductible to pay off first either.

In Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas, Miami and more than a dozen other markets, people seeking coverage through the insurance exchanges can choose health plans providing free doctor visits, a benefit once considered unthinkable.

The change is rolling out in a limited number of plans following reports that high copays and deductibles have discouraged many Americans who signed up for private coverage the past two years from using their new insurance under the Affordable Care Act.

Insurers say they hope encouraging visits to doctors will benefit members and their bottom lines by catching illnesses early before they become harder and more expensive to treat. For example, prescribing antibiotics promptly to a patient with pneumonia could avoid a lengthy hospitalization costing tens of thousands of dollars.

In addition, the policy could also cut down on the use of more expensive urgent care centers and emergency rooms for cases that aren’t critical.

In most states, Dec. 15 was the deadline for coverage starting Jan. 1, though people have until Jan. 31 to enroll for 2016.

Two new health insurers, Harken Health, an independently operated affiliate of UnitedHealthcare, and Zoom+ are offering unlimited free primary care visits at company-owned clinics. Harken operates in Chicago and Atlanta. Zoom+ is based in Portland, Ore.

Down south, Florida Blue, the state’s largest insurer, has health plans in Miami-Dade and nine other counties where low-income members buying plans can also get two free primary care visits per year.

California-based Molina Healthcare, is offering not only free primary care visits in some plans, but also free visits to specialists in Florida, Texas and five other states.

The no-fee visits go beyond the preventive services, such as immunizations and screenings, that all insurers must provide under Obamacare without charging a copay, even when a deductible hasn’t been met.

Health policy experts say the new approach sets the insurers apart in crowded insurance markets and may attract younger, healthier people who don’t have relationships with doctors.

“This is a great development … and shows how the market is trying to innovate,” said Katherine Hempstead, director of coverage for the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.

“Consumers should find this very appealing. … It might be like ‘a spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down,’ ” she said, quoting a line from the Mary Poppins song. “People are not going to grouse as much about cost sharing later if they are getting something free first.”

Consumer advocates applaud the trend, which they say underscores why people need to look beyond the monthly premium when shopping for a plan. “It’s a smart move to reduce financial barriers to basic outpatient care to help patients manage their health,” said Lydia Mitts, a senior policy analyst at Families USA. “I hope other health plans will realize removing financial barriers to primary care doctors is a smart direction for patients and for the plans.”

The health plans offering free doctor visits are typically among the lowest-priced plans in many markets, according to a Kaiser Health News review of plans sold on the exchanges.

Some insurers can offer free visits because they operate health clinics staffed by salaried physicians. That’s the case at Harken Health, which has four primary care clinics in Chicago and six in Atlanta for its members to use for unlimited visits. Harken also offers members access to a doctor by telephone and Internet. “We are creating unfettered access between the care team and the patients,” said Tom Vanderheyden, CEO of Harken Health. “We think it’s a significant differentiation.” Harken also offers free yoga and cooking classes.

Patients with easy access to Harken’s clinics should be able to avoid trips to urgent care centers, retail clinics and emergency rooms, and develop a deeper relationship with their primary care doctor, Vanderheyden said. “Better access … should mean better outcomes and happier people.”

Dave Sanders, CEO of Zoom+ and a physician, said offering free doctor visits at its modern clinics, should help attract young enrollees. “We are unabashedly focused on the millennial generation,” he said.

To that end, Zoom+ lets members make appointments using a smartphone app. The company’s doctors emphasize changing diets before prescribing drugs.

Dr. Craig McDougall of ZOOM+ talks about food as medicine with a patient visiting one of the insurer's clinics in Portland, Ore.

Dr. Craig McDougall of ZOOM+ talks about food as medicine with a patient visiting one of the insurer’s clinics in Portland, Ore. Courtesy of Zoom hide caption

toggle caption Courtesy of Zoom

Zoom+ has run clinics in the Portland area for the past year, but it has never offered an insurance plan before. Members can get free care at the clinics or Zoom’s freestanding emergency room.

Under the health law, marketplace plans must cover a certain percentage of a member’s health costs with the amount varying based on gold, silver or bronze tiers. “What we have done is to spend the resources on primary care,” Sanders said.

Zoom+ also offers free mental health visits and one free dental visit for a cleaning.

Florida Blue, the state’s Blue Cross and Blue Shield plan, developed a new product for 2016 called myBlue which offers two free primary care doctor visits and then charges $1 a visit thereafter, $3 visits for specialists, free routine lab tests and free diabetic supplies. The myBlue plan was created to help people whose incomes qualify for the highest cost-sharing subsidies under the Affordable Care Act.

To offer such benefits, Florida Blue developed a smaller network of doctors, hospitals and pharmacies so it could better control costs. But to encourage enrollment in Miami-Dade County it recently partnered with three CliniSanitas medical clinics, which primarily serve the Hispanic audience in the area. The plan is also available across South Florida, and counties around Tampa and Orlando.

Jon Urbanek, a senior vice president for Florida Blue, said the new plan is intended to increase the insurer’s market share. He said participating providers in the myBlue products are not necessarily paid less than other doctors but their pay is more closely tied to reaching certain quality targets such as cancer and cholesterol screenings. In 6 of 10 counties where it’s available, the myBlue product offers the lowest premium. “We think our pricing positions us to do very well,” Urbanek said.

Molina Healthcare is offering zero copays for unlimited primary care doctor visits for one of its silver-tier plans for 2016. Unlike Florida Blue, it says it offers free doctor visits in its plans without using a narrow network of doctors and hospitals. “We really want folks to get value from their premium dollar and not have any barriers for care,” said Lisa Rubino, senior vice president at Molina.

Molina offers the zero copay doctor plans in Florida, Michigan, New Mexico, Ohio, Texas, Utah and Wisconsin.

This story was produced through collaboration between NPR and Kaiser Health News, an editorially independent program of the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation, a nonpartisan health care policy research organization. Neither the foundation nor the news service is affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.

This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service – if this is your content and you’re reading it on someone else’s site, please read the FAQ at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php#publishers.